Discussion across the Atmosphere
The revolt of the reader | The Observation Deck
bcantrill.dtrace.org
Read on bcantrill.dtrace.org1 linkblog note · 53 Bluesky posts · 2 margin.at saves · 5 Semble saves
Highlights
-
sōm ⁂ @hyl.st
the standard for our public writing is not merely that LLMs aren’t used to write, but that readers have the confidence that it’s not LLM-authored
-
seth @seth.computer
as Cynthia Dunlop writes, of the 668 developers that replied to her survey, 78% "stop reading immediately" when they detect an LLM. And there are consequences that outlast the piece: 71% of the respondents in Cynthia’s survey also "avoid the author in the future" (!!)
Discussion
-
sōm ⁂ @hyl.st
It's literally harmful to expose people to output tokens. I do my best to minimize the amount of output tokens I read, especially if it's just text.
-
Saša Jurić @sasajuric.bsky.social
"If your position is that we should be fine with an LLM crafting prose from your prompt, spare us all the wasted cycles and just give us your prompt."
-
Charity Majors @charity.wtf
The final post on this topic comes from @bcantrill.bsky.social, two weeks before Matheus and I got ours together. (Typical Cantrill.) It is called "The revolt of the reader." ... and now I am on my way to procure a Pangram browser plugin, by hook or by crook.
-
Hayden (he/him) @hds.cafe
I've read 3 good blog posts on this topic in the last couple of weeks. - @bcantrill.bsky.social: - @charity.wtf: - @terriblesoftware.org
-
Arseny Kapoulkine @zeux.io
-
Lev Lazinskiy🌈 @levlaz.org
I can't stop using Pangram ever since reading @bcantrill.bsky.social excellent post "The revolt of the reader"
-
David Faden @util.bsky.social
Appreciating @bcantrill.bsky.social standing up for readers: Wonder if expectations on grammar and flow will increase as writing aides improve, stifling style somewhat. I'm imagining built-in spell check earlier increased pressure to get spelling "right"?
-
Peter Friese @peterfriese.dev
Even with "humanizer" prompts, AI writing always has a tell. Bryan Cantrill writes on the revolt of the reader, and why relying on LLMs to write your prose drives your audience away instead of growing it
-
todd @trpalmer.bsky.social
"we readers shouldn’t be expected to labor to understand a sentence that the writer themselves didn’t work to create."
Saved in
-
Joe Germuska @joe.germuska.com
-
Tomas Latal @tomaslatal.cz
Revealingly, the respondents are not after linguistic perfection, but rather authenticity: 98% reported preferring an author’s own (imperfectly) written piece over an LLM-polished one.
-
seth @seth.computer
-
Ronen Tamari @ronentk.me
-
-
Tim Disney @disnetdev.com